Four Years of Sales: What Has Changed in San Carlos?

Home > Blog > Newsletter > Four Years of Sales: What Has Changed in San Carlos?
Four Years of Sales: What Has Changed in San Carlos?

Another month has come and gone, and October wasn't exactly the one that sparked the real estate market in San Carlos. With just $713,821 in closed sales, there wasn't much to get excited about.

Instead of subjecting everyone to yet another recap of a quiet month, we decided to dig a little deeper into the numbers. We went back to 2023—the last year we could reasonably describe as a good one—and compared the first ten months of each year through October 2026.

It turned out that the exercise was worth it. We found some things we expected, a couple that surprised us, and a particularly interesting distinction between the number of properties sold and the prices they fetch.

For those who prefer their real estate news in small doses, here are the main points.

The Market at a Glance

January–October 2026, compared with the same period in 2023

  • 83 properties sold, compared with 115 in 2023, a 28% decline.
  • $29.85 million in closed sales, compared with $37.43 million.
  • 51 homes sold, compared with 58 in 2023.
  • Median home sales price: $320,000, compared to $322,369 in 2023.
  • 17 condos sold, compared to 30 in 2023.
  • 15 residential lots sold, compared to 25 in 2023.

And here's the interesting part. We have significantly fewer transactions than in 2023, but the median home sales price is almost exactly where it was four years ago.

That's worth a closer look.

Closed Transactions by Property Type, 2023–2026

Lower Sales—But What About Prices?

We've been telling you for some time now that the real estate market has been slowing down. The last truly active year was 2023, and neither 2024 nor 2025 gave us much to celebrate.

What caught our attention when comparing the last four years was not so much the decline in the number of transactions—which we were already aware of—but rather how little the median home sales price has changed.

In 2023, the median was approximately $322,000. In 2024, it was $317,000, followed by $305,000 in 2025. This year, it stands at $320,000.

It is a surprisingly narrow range, considering the changes in sales activity.

We deliberately chose the median rather than the average sales price. In a market as small as San Carlos, a single large sale can make a big difference. In October 2025, a house sold for $2.1 million, while in 2026 there was a transaction for $2.4 million. Both influence the averages, but neither comes close to changing the median by that much.

Of course, these figures do not mean that all properties have retained their value. We are comparing homes that were actually sold, not the same set of properties changing hands each year.

Median Selling Price by Property Type, 2023–2026

Where Did the Activity Go?

The market for single-family homes has held up better than the overall sales figures would suggest. We recorded 58 home sales during the first ten months of 2023, compared with 51 this year.

The largest differences have been seen in condominiums and residential lots.

Condominium sales fell from 30 in 2023 to 17 this year, while lot sales dropped from 25 to 15. Both categories have improved compared to 2025, although activity remains well below 2023 levels.

There is another difference worth mentioning. Commercial transactions contributed to the 2023 totals, whereas in 2026 we have not recorded any commercial sales.

A Little Perspective

Four years of data allow for an interesting comparison. The number of transactions has undoubtedly changed, and there’s no denying that the market has been considerably quieter.

Even so, the median home sales price has remained remarkably close to where it was in 2023.

That may be the most interesting finding in this month's figures. Fewer properties are changing hands, but the median price at which homes are selling has changed very little.

Photo credit: Alfonso “RADA” Vásquez